← All mentions

Janette Toral · November 13, 2026

Are Online Sellers Building Businesses or Building Dependence on Platforms?

Janette Toral published this in the LinkedIn newsletter Digital Leaders on November 13, 2026. Reprinted here with permission. Read the original.

At the Cross Border Summit in Chiang Mai, Thailand, one of the discussions that caught my attention was how established e-commerce businesses were reassessing the platforms that had helped them grow.

During her presentation, the founder of SuperBee Antoinette Jackson discussed the company’s efforts to expand its distribution channels while becoming more selective about its presence on Amazon. Equally interesting was the company’s emphasis on product value, brand storytelling, and advocacy as a way to stand apart from price-driven competition.

The experience raised a question worth considering, especially for entrepreneurs whose businesses have grown through online marketplaces: Are they building businesses with lasting value, or are they becoming increasingly dependent on platforms they do not control?

Digital marketplaces have made entrepreneurship more accessible. Amazon, Shopee, Lazada, and other platforms provide access to customers, payment systems, promotional tools, and fulfillment services that would otherwise require significant investments. For many small businesses, joining an established marketplace is a sensible way to begin selling online.

As sales grow, however, entrepreneurs need to understand how much of their success depends on continued access to these platforms and what would happen if that access changed.

When access becomes a business risk

Much of the discussion about marketplace dependence focuses on rising commissions, advertising costs, and promotional discounts. These affect profitability, but another risk deserves equal attention: the possibility of losing the ability to sell.

A seller may spend years developing products, building customer reviews, and investing in marketplace advertising, only to encounter a listing suspension or account restriction.

An intellectual property complaint, for example, can lead to enforcement action while a dispute is being reviewed. Complaints may involve legitimate concerns, misunderstandings, contested rights, or allegations that sellers believe are unfounded. Regardless of the eventual outcome, the disruption can be costly.

For a business that relies heavily on one marketplace, the consequences may extend to unsold inventory, interrupted cash flow, delayed orders, and reduced customer access. The seller may also face uncertainty about how long a review or appeal will take.

Platforms have legitimate responsibilities to protect consumers, intellectual property owners, and the integrity of their marketplaces. Sellers, in turn, need to understand the rules and maintain documentation that can help them demonstrate compliance.

Product records, supplier invoices, intellectual property documentation, and relevant compliance evidence should be organized before a problem arises. Business owners should also familiarize themselves with dispute and appeal procedures.

These preparations can improve a seller’s ability to respond when problems occur. They also highlight why platform dependence deserves attention as a business continuity concern alongside selling costs.

Sales concentration tells only part of the story

A business generating most of its revenue through one marketplace is highly concentrated in that channel. Its actual vulnerability, however, depends on several other factors.

Consider two hypothetical sellers.

The first generates 80 percent of its sales through one marketplace. It has a recognizable brand, established supplier relationships, repeat demand, and experience serving customers through other channels.

The second generates sales across several platforms but depends heavily on paid promotions and marketplace recommendations to attract customers. Buyers recognize its products primarily through prices rather than brand identity.

Both businesses face risks, yet their ability to adapt may differ considerably.

The first seller has substantial channel concentration but possesses capabilities that could support a transition if conditions change. The second appears diversified while remaining vulnerable to rising customer acquisition costs and shifts in platform visibility.

For business owners, understanding where sales happen is only part of the assessment. They also need to understand what makes those sales possible.

This distinction helps explain why adding more online stores may offer limited protection. Every additional channel brings expenses, operational requirements, and new service-provider relationships.

A direct-to-consumer website, for instance, may give a business greater control over its customer experience. It also requires investments in attracting visitors, processing payments, managing orders, handling customer concerns, and fulfilling deliveries.

The decision to expand distribution should therefore consider whether another channel improves profitability, customer access, or resilience enough to justify its costs.

Giving customers a reason to choose the brand

Super Bee’s approach offered another lesson that deserves attention.

Its emphasis on brand story, advocacy, and product value illustrates how businesses can compete while maintaining a clear identity in price-sensitive markets.

Online marketplaces make comparisons convenient. Customers can quickly examine competing products, prices, ratings, and delivery options. For sellers offering products that appear interchangeable, discounting can become an easy way to attract attention.

The difficulty is that competitors can also lower their prices. A business that depends primarily on discounts may find itself continually sacrificing margins to maintain sales.

Differentiation gives customers additional reasons to make a purchase.

For Super Bee, its brand identity and advocacy are part of how it communicates value. Other businesses may distinguish themselves through product quality, specialization, reliability, convenience, design, or customer service.

A Filipino food producer, for example, may compete through consistent quality, distinctive ingredients, and dependable fulfillment rather than matching every promotional discount offered by larger competitors. A specialty manufacturer may earn repeat orders because buyers trust its specifications and production standards.

Brand storytelling can help customers understand these differences, provided the promises are supported by the actual product and customer experience.

This matters for platform resilience because a recognizable brand can create demand that extends beyond a particular marketplace listing. Customers who appreciate what a business offers may be more willing to seek it through other legitimate distribution channels.

A strong brand provides an advantage that can remain valuable across different selling environments. Its reputation, customer trust, and product differentiation become assets the business can continue developing over time.

The economics still have to work

A strong brand and alternative distribution channels are valuable when they contribute to a commercially sustainable business.

One recurring concern during the summit was the pressure on profitability as sellers manage advertising expenses, sourcing costs, logistics, returns, and other operational requirements.

A marketplace can generate impressive sales volumes while leaving relatively little profit after all costs are considered.

Selling directly also involves expenses. A business may avoid certain marketplace commissions while spending more on advertising, website maintenance, payment processing, customer support, and fulfillment.

Business owners therefore need to understand the contribution of each channel, including its costs and the customers it brings.

A marketplace that consistently introduces profitable new customers may justify its fees. A channel that requires repeated discounts and expensive advertising may warrant adjustments in pricing, product mix, or marketing strategy.

These decisions become increasingly important as a business expands. Additional channels, products, and markets can increase revenue while stretching inventory, working capital, and management attention.

In some situations, improving an existing operation, strengthening supplier arrangements, or discontinuing activities with weak returns may contribute more to long-term profitability than further expansion.

What should businesses do differently?

For entrepreneurs, a practical response begins with understanding their existing operations and identifying the capabilities that deserve greater attention.

Start with channel profitability. Examine revenue alongside customer acquisition costs, fulfillment expenses, returns, promotional spending, and the contribution each platform makes to the business. This provides a clearer basis for deciding where to invest.

Prepare for interruptions. Maintain appropriate business records, product documentation, intellectual property information, and account security measures. Understand marketplace procedures and consider how inventory, customer obligations, and cash flow would be managed during a disruption.

Strengthen the reasons customers choose the business. Product differentiation, consistent quality, dependable service, and credible brand communication help create demand that can extend across distribution channels.

These actions are relevant to businesses at different stages of development.

A new seller may reasonably concentrate on one marketplace while building a reputation and learning the economics of online selling. A more established business may be ready to explore wholesale relationships, direct distribution, or additional markets.

The appropriate strategy depends on the company’s resources, customers, operational capabilities, and commercial objectives. Each business needs to make deliberate choices about where to grow and which capabilities to strengthen.

Building a business that can withstand change

The Cross Border Summit reinforced an important consideration for entrepreneurs experiencing growth through online marketplaces. Strong marketplace sales can create opportunities for expansion, but long-term business resilience requires capabilities that extend beyond the sales channel itself.

Marketplaces can remain valuable partners throughout a company’s development. Their infrastructure and customer reach may continue to provide advantages that would be difficult or expensive to reproduce independently.

At the same time, businesses benefit from preparing for circumstances in which commercial terms change, competition intensifies, or access is interrupted.

That preparation involves understanding where the business earns money, maintaining the records and processes needed to protect its operations, and developing products and brands that customers have genuine reasons to choose.

For established businesses, it may also involve difficult decisions about which channels deserve further investment and which have become less aligned with the company’s direction.

A resilient online business understands the value of its platforms, prepares for the risks associated with them, and builds capabilities that allow it to adapt as conditions change.

Ultimately, the strength of an online business rests on more than the number of platforms where it sells. Its products, reputation, customer trust, operational discipline, and ability to make sound commercial decisions determine how well it can sustain growth over time.

Janette Toral at CBS 2026 LinkedIn original

Cross Border Summit · 2026 · Fellowship

2026 tickets are closed.

The summit is underway at Chiang Mai Orchid Hotel, Chiang Mai, Thailand. Find the latest summit at crossbordersummit.com.

Theme · Fellowship Date · November 3–5, 2026 Venue · Chiang Mai Orchid Hotel